Hmmm. My thoughts on this whole TIME magazine / attachment parenting debate seem to change daily. In the main it has been a positive thing for me, because it (and people’s responses to it) have been food for thought and have caused me to examine my own approaches to parenting and how easy it is to judge others for what they do. But something about it is also starting to leave a bad taste in my mouth.
I’ve read some amazing commentary, both here on Tumblr (Little Jacksons, Dover and Yellow Sparkle Onion Rings to name a few), and other blogs, which has made a lot of sense to me. And succinctly put, here is what I think: I think the idea that anyone would subscribe rigidly to one style of parenting because they read it in a book is bogus. Most of us look at our options, (online, in books, at the people around us), and choose those that best suit us. I think that unless you are doing something that could cause harm to your baby (and no, I do not include feeding them formula and pushing them in a pram in that, OBVS), then what you do is your own business. And I think that we can all learn from each others as mothers and that there are always things that we can do better, in parenting, as in life generally.
Less succinctly, here are some more things that I think:
I think that I wouldn’t want to label myself as any particular type of Mum (well, hopefully a FREAKING AWESOME ONE). Ahem. Seriously though, I have made choices as a Mum that are right for me and my family. These include breast feeding and baby wearing, as well as getting my baby into a routine and putting him to sleep in a cot. I didn’t make these choices because i thought they would win me some badges of honur in this online game called ‘alternative parenting’, i made them because i thought they were sweet and easy and might bring my baby a little bit of happiness. And yes, I am passionate about those choices and have put up information about some of those things on my blog, because I hope that they may be of use to people who are considering doing the same. And no, if you don’t make those same choices, I will not think that you are some sort of terrible mother, because that would be insane.
But I don’t know, lately I feel like in saying that I’m passionate about something like baby wearing, that people will infer from that I am being critical of people who use a pram. Or that I must have some holier than thou attitude. And it seems like the formula feeders get all defensive because they feel like the breast feeders are criticising them, and then the breast feeders get all defensive, because they feel like the formula feeders are criticising them for criticising them. And I’m like, does anyone actually care? Seriously? Like, anyone?
A common response to seeing my baby in cloth is, “Oh, you’re so good, I should do that, but I [insert numerous excuses here].” And I don’t get it. I’m not ‘good’ because I use cloth nappies, and I certainly don’t judge anyone as ‘bad’ because they don’t. I freaking love cloth, because I personally like reducing my waste and it saves me money and I think they’re cute. Do I therefore think that everyone should think and do the same? Of course not. Do I think I’m better than my friends who use disposables because of my choice? No, because I’m not an idiot.
I’m still not sure exactly where I stand. I seem to swing between feeling as if I should make known that I am not critical or judgemental of other people’s parenting choices, and then wondering why I even need to qualify that. I guess we all have our insecurities about our abilities as parents, and they tend to get magnified and played out in this weird old space we call the Internet. Because I’ve gotta tell you people are an awful lot more judgmental online than they are in real life, where actually, no one gives a damn about what we’re doing. No one is sitting at home, thinking about you and why you’re not baby wearing. No one cares that you use cloth nappies, or will be popping round any time soon to give you a medal. No one is celebrating the fact that your baby can walk at 6 months, because, let’s be frank they’ve got a baby of their own, who probably won’t go to sleep, or a heap of laundry to wash, or a bathroom to clean.
So that, in the nicest possible way, is my final word. No one gives a damn. So let’s move it on now.